Choosing a BI tool: the criteria that matter
A BI tools comparison built on criteria, not rankings: data sources, users, sharing, licences, embedding and skills, and when a custom dashboard is better.


Your monthly reports still come out of spreadsheets. Someone exports data from three tools, pastes it into Excel, fixes the formulas and emails a file that is out of date by the time it is opened. So you start looking at business intelligence (BI) software, and every BI tools comparison you find ends with a different winner.
This article won’t name a winner. The right tool depends on your data, your people and how you share figures, not on a ranking. We give you the six criteria that decide the choice, the main families of tools, a grid to score them, and the cases where a custom dashboard is the better answer.
Start with the decisions, not the software
Before comparing products, write down three things:
- the decisions the figures should inform: which customers to follow up, which products to reorder, where margin is slipping;
- the people who will read the reports, and how often;
- the sources the figures come from today.
If you have not yet chosen which indicators to track, start there: our guide to the KPIs that matter on an executive dashboard helps you pick a short list.
Be honest about scale: if two people read one monthly report from one source, a good spreadsheet may still be enough. A BI tool earns its place when sources, readers or hours of manual work multiply.
The six criteria in a BI tools comparison
1. Your data sources
List every source: accounting software, CRM (customer relationship management), ERP (enterprise resource planning), e-commerce site, spreadsheets, a database. For each one, check whether the tool offers a ready-made connector, whether it refreshes automatically, and how often. When your reports must combine many of these sources, with shared definitions and history, a data warehouse can prepare the data before the BI tool displays it.
A connector listed on a vendor’s site is not proof: test it with your own data. If your key data still lives in scattered spreadsheets, the first project may be replacing Excel with a business app, so that the figures have one reliable home.
2. Who builds and who reads
Most teams have a few builders, who prepare data and design reports, and many readers, who only consult them.
Builders need a tool that matches their skills: some tools are made for analysts comfortable with formulas or SQL (the language used to query databases), others for managers who prefer drag-and-drop. Readers need clear pages that load quickly, work on a phone and require no training.
3. Sharing and security
Ask how a report reaches its readers: a web link, an app, an email, a screen in the office. Then ask who sees what: can a regional manager see only their region? Can people sign in with their company accounts (single sign-on, or SSO)?
Where the data is stored also matters. If your reports contain personal data, the data protection rules that apply to your company, such as the GDPR in the European Union, have consequences for where it is hosted and who can access it. Check the vendor’s hosting regions and ask your adviser when in doubt.
4. The licence model
BI tools are billed per user (often with different prices for builders and readers), by capacity or by usage. Some are free for one author but charge as soon as you share. We don’t quote prices: they change often.
What matters is the shape of the bill. Count your builders and readers today and in three years, then ask each vendor for a written quote for both situations. A tool that is cheap for five readers can become expensive for fifty.
5. Embedding in your own application
You may want figures to appear inside your own software or customer portal rather than in a separate tool. Most major BI tools offer embedding, but often through a specific edition or licence, with development work to secure each viewer’s data. If embedding is the main need, weight it heavily.
6. The skills you have, or can get
Who will fix a report when a source changes? If the answer is “nobody”, choose the simplest tool your team can maintain, or plan for outside help. A familiar tool people use beats a powerful one only a consultant understands.
The main families of BI tools
As of October 2026, the market falls into a few broad families. The products named here are examples, not recommendations: check each vendor’s current editions before deciding.
| Family | Examples | Often a good fit when… | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Suites linked to an office ecosystem | Microsoft Power BI, Google Looker Studio | Your company already works in Microsoft 365 or Google Workspace | Sharing and advanced features often depend on a paid edition |
| Dedicated analytics platforms | Tableau, Qlik | You have analysts and complex data to explore | Licences and skills can weigh more than the software suggests |
| Open-source tools you host yourself | Metabase, Apache Superset | You have technical people and want control over hosting | Hosting, updates and security are your job |
| Reports built into your business software | The reporting module of your ERP or CRM | Most of your figures already live in one tool | Hard to combine with data from other tools |
Power BI vs Tableau, or Power BI vs Looker Studio?
These are the most searched comparisons, and the answer depends on context, not on which product is “better”. A company working in Microsoft 365 will often find Power BI the natural first step. A team working in Google Workspace with Google Analytics data will often start with Looker Studio. Tableau is frequently chosen by teams with dedicated analysts.
A decision grid to compare BI tools
Score two or three shortlisted tools from 1 to 5 on each criterion, then multiply by a weight that reflects your priorities.
| Criterion | Question to answer during the trial | Weight (1–3) |
|---|---|---|
| Data sources | Do our three main sources connect and refresh without manual work? | |
| Builders | Can our builder create a useful report in a day, alone? | |
| Readers | Can a manager find their figure on a phone in under a minute? | |
| Sharing and security | Can we restrict each person to their own data? | |
| Licences | What is the written quote for today’s users, and for three times as many? | |
| Embedding | If needed: can figures appear in our own app, securely? | |
| Skills | Who maintains it, and what happens if they leave? |
Illustrative example (fictitious figures): a distributor with 2 builders and 30 readers weights data sources at 3, readers at 3 and embedding at 1. Two tools score close overall, but one needs a paid licence for every reader; the written quotes, not the feature lists, settle the choice.
When a custom dashboard is the better answer
An off-the-shelf BI tool is the right default for most SMEs. A custom dashboard, built into your own application, makes sense when:
- the figures must appear inside your software or portal, for customers or partners, with each person seeing only their data;
- the logic behind the figures is specific to your business and painful to rebuild in a generic tool;
- the number of readers makes per-user licences a lasting cost;
- the figures must trigger actions in the application, not just be read.
Our article on off-the-shelf or custom software gives the general method. Often the answer is mixed: a BI tool for internal analysis, and a few key figures inside the business application.
Reliable reporting also starts with data captured in one place. At Innova Home, in Morocco, the custom software designed by our founder replaced paper and spreadsheets with a single tool, saving more than 50% of the time spent on each order. With data entered once in a structured tool, reporting becomes far simpler.
Frequently asked questions
Is Power BI or Tableau better for a small business?
Neither is better in general. The deciding factors are your sources, your builders’ skills and the licence cost for all your readers, and as of October 2026 both vendors offer several editions. Run a short trial of both with your own data, and ask for written quotes based on your real number of users.
Is a free BI tool enough to start?
Often, yes, for a first step. Some tools have a free edition, and open-source tools have no licence fee. The costs then appear elsewhere: paid editions for sharing, hosting and maintenance for self-hosted tools, or time spent working around limits. Before investing time in reports, check what sharing with your whole team will require.
How long does it take to set up business intelligence software?
It depends more on your data than on the tool. Connecting a clean source can be quick; cleaning inconsistent spreadsheets, agreeing on definitions (what counts as a “sale”?) and setting access rights take longer. Start with one report for one decision, then extend.
In short
The best BI tool is the one that fits your sources, your builders, your readers and your budget for years to come, not the one at the top of a ranking. Score two or three tools on six criteria, test them with your own data and compare written quotes. And consider a custom dashboard when figures belong inside your own application.
Still building your reports by hand every month? Book a free 30-minute discovery call: together, we’ll look at your sources and your decisions, and see whether a BI tool, a custom dashboard or a better spreadsheet is the right next step. You can also read more about our data and BI expertise.
Related servicesData & BI
Let’s talk about it on a 30-minute discovery call, free and with no obligation.
Get our next articles in your feed: follow AnazTech on LinkedIn.Follow on LinkedIn






